2.3.12 and 2.3.14 Profile Performance Comparison

Coordinator
Sep 15, 2012 at 7:03 AM
Edited Sep 15, 2012 at 7:04 AM

HUGE Thanks to Vladimir for helping put this comparison table together.

2 sample files, MPEG2 SD recordings, 1hr each
Source -> Cracker, iTV3, Freesat UK
1.3 GB WTV file each

Both:

704x576 at 25 fps
RemoveAds=No
DownloadSerialInfo=No
EverythingElse=Default Values

Results (average)

Profile Time Size Comment
MP4 High Quality 1hr : 43min 832 MB (Main encodes (except 1stPass in High Quality) using all cores)
MP4 Normal 53min 844 MB (Main encodes using all cores)
MP4 Fast 24min 917 MB (Main encodes using all cores)
M4V Apple High Quality 1hr : 1min 908 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
M4V Apple Normal 32min 919 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
M4V Apple Fast 24min 917 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
DivX AVI High Quality 6hr : 5min 691 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
Divx AVI Normal 1hr : 11min 575 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
Divx AVI Fast 18min 827 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
MKV High Quality 1hr : 2min 832 MB (Main encodes (except 1stPass in High Quality) using all cores)
MKV Normal Quality 27min 829 MB (Main encodes using all cores)
NoRecode AVI Highest Quality 2min 869 MB  
NoRecode AVI Fix High Quality 6min 1500 MB  
TS from WTV/DVRMS/TS 1min 964 MB  
TS Recode High Quality 6min 1600 MB  
WMV High Quality 1hr : 2min 944 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)
WMV Normal Quality 27min 939 MB (Main encodes Using all cores)

 

Nov 27, 2013 at 9:27 PM
Thanks. For comparison purposes, what hardware and MCEBuddy version did you use for this test?
Nov 28, 2013 at 9:16 AM
For this comparison I've used 2.3.12 version.

I'm at the moment finishing testing with 2.3.14 FINAL version and should have results this weekend.
Dec 4, 2013 at 2:51 AM
Excellent, if you have a script to automate testing the different formats I would be happy to add more datapoints.
Jan 9, 2014 at 8:56 PM
Any luck on the new results?
Jan 30, 2014 at 3:18 PM
bump.
any updates?
Coordinator
Jan 31, 2014 at 5:54 PM
Here are some more results posted by another user:

http://mcebuddy2x.codeplex.com/discussions/509545
Coordinator
Jan 31, 2014 at 6:07 PM

Updated results with 2.3.14, thanks to @Vladik007 for his effort in doing and putting it together:

Original File: SD Resolution, MPEG2, 60 Minutes, 857Mb

RESULTS:
Profile                    Time    Size

MP4 High Quality           0:42:26 659 Mb
MP4 Normal                 0:14:43 512 Mb
MP4 Fast                   0:09:46 394 Mb

M4V Apple High Quality     0:19:49 596 Mb
M4V Apple Normal           0:13:11 522 Mb
M4V Fast                   0:09:22 393 Mb

MKV High Quality           0:38:22 658 Mb
MKV Normal                 0:12:42 510 Mb
MKV Fast                   0:08:58 443 Mb

DIVX Avi High Quality      1:54:57 662 Mb
DIVX Normal                0:40:58 518 Mb
DIVX Fast                  0:07:52 456 Mb

TS                         0:08:12 2,41 Gb

WTV                        0:08:24 2,25 Gb

WMV High Quality           0:19:47 741 Mb
WMV Normal                 0:09:30 551 Mb

iPhone                     0:12:23 414 Mb
iPhone Hi-Res              0:13:38 1,11 Gb
iPad                       0:13:36 927 Mb
iPad Hi-Res                0:23:50 3,42 Gb

VCD MPG                    0:08:46 604 Mb
DVD TS                     0:10:24 1,53 Gb
DVD VOB                    0:10:32 1,53 Gb
3GP                        0:07:22 360 Mb

Avi MPEG-2                 0:08:28 2,23 Gb

MKV Unprocessed            0:03:33 810 Mb
TS Unprocessed             0:02:04 884 Mb
MP4 Unprocessed            0:03:40 810 Mb
WTV Unprocessed            0:04:03 838 Mb
Avi MPEG-2 Unprocessed     0:04:57 816 Mb
Marked as answer by rboy1 on 1/31/2014 at 11:07 AM